by Ben Luxon October 30, 2019 5 min read

0 Comments

An age-old question and a hard one to answer. Is investing in buy-to-let properties better or worse than investing in the stock market?

The answer as always with these types of things isn’t a simple yes or no, there is an array of contributing factors which means it’s different for everyone. One thing though, that seems to be universally suggested by the ‘experts’ is that you should diversify your investments and create multiple streams of income. To me, this suggests that maybe it's not a question of which is better, rather one of identifying the strengths and weaknesses of each wealth-building strategy. 

So, in this article, we thought we’d take a look at a few of the advantages of both and some of their disadvantages.

The Advantages of Real Estate Investing Over Stocks

1. Hold an asset

When you invest in a property you invest in something tangible you physically own a tangible asset. The value of that asset might fluctuate, but at the end of the day, a house is still a house. This is a serious advantage of property investing. Apart from in the case of unexpected disasters eg. natural disasters, your property will always be your property.

The same can’t be said for stocks. The value of stocks is determined, amongst other things by speculation. The company(s) that you invest in might collapse and, as I learned the hard way, over-exuberant speculation can lead to massive downturns in the market. I’m currently sitting on one stock which after valuing themselves too highly dropped over 20% overnight (but that’s why we diversify, I suppose).

Property over stocks

2. Create cashflow

The second big benefit of owning buy-to-let properties is creating a positive cashflow property. This isn't necessarily easy, but if it can be managed you could be getting hundreds of dollars a month in profit from a down payment of as little as 20% on a single property.

3. Build equity

By building equity we mean you can use the cash flow of the property to pay off the mortgage and reduce the debt. Whilst pocketing some cash at the same time. You can, in a gross over-simplification, imagine it a bit like a savings account.

4. Property appreciation

The final benefit of owning a property is appreciation. This is particularly important if you buy especially low. Properties naturally increase in value over time, and if you hold a property for a significant amount of time the capital gains made through appreciation could be startling.

The Advantages of Stocks Over Real Estate

1. Can offer better year on year growth than a property

While properties do appreciate in value, good shares can increase in value faster. For example, house prices went up by an average of 4.9% over the last year, however, S&P 500 went up 21% in 2017 and 6.47% in 2018. Neither is to be sniffed at, however, one is definitely higher than the other.

2. You can invest as little or as much as you like.

One of the major problems with investing in real estate is that it costs a lot of money. In general, you need to place at least 20% of the value of the property down which on a cheap property of $150,000, means you’re looking at cash upfront of $30,000. Plus you then have to assume the debt of $120,000 plus interest (which not everyone will qualify for).

With the stock market though you can begin investing with much smaller amounts - though of course, you aren’t going to see the same big cash returns on a $50 investment as you would with $30,000.

Stocks over property

3. Your cash remains more liquid (you can resell your shares any time)

Tieing your money up in property can mean you no longer have access to that cash. Selling a property can take months and being forced to sell could mean taking a big loss. Stocks, in comparison, are easier to trade and you could get you money out and back into cash in as little as a few hours. What this means is that if for some reason you need your money - perhaps an excellent investment opportunity arises that you need to move on quickly - then stocks allow a lot more flexibility.

4. It’s low maintenance - just let them grow.

Buying stocks is easy (in theory) - you research and buy them and leave them to grow. Then they either go up or down in value, hopefully up of course. On the other hand, a rental property can be quite a handful to manage with maintenance, tenants, and accounts to deal with.

5. Collect dividends

Whilst you don’t get the same cash returns some stocks offer dividend payouts, either monthly or quarterly which can add up to some impressive gains.

A Bit of Both -  REITs

We’ve talked about REITs in the past and it was personally my first foray into real estate investing. Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) are a way for people to invest in real estate without having to front all the cash for a property. Instead, they allow you to invest in a diversified portfolio of real estate held in trust. This portfolio pays regular dividends, anywhere between 3% and 10% a year, and your investment should appreciate in line with the properties values that are held.

REITs then, on paper seem like a good compromise. You get a lot of the benefits of property investing and stocks without the high monetary entry barrier and the assumption of mortgage debts. However, again, you won’t receive the same cash returns as you would with a property investment 

Summary

In the long run, investing in properties is likely to see you build wealth more efficiently. It allows you to purchase an asset and use the asset to pay off its own debts whilst making you some cash. The property will then likely appreciate over the time that you hold it (though not necessarily).

However, investing in stocks and shares is easier, comes with a lower monetary barrier and allows you to keep your money more liquid and accessible in case you need to access it quickly. Plus, whilst an S&P 500 has over the years returned a good average of 8%, there are plenty of stocks and shares that return far higher - just imagine if you’d bought shares in Apple for example in 1980. An investment then of $220 would now be worth $112,268.8, not including dividends. Of course on the flip side, Apple is a one in a million company and betting on volatile stocks could quite easily see you lose money rather than gain.

Thanks for reading and we hope you found this blog interesting! However, do note that the purposes of this article is for general information. We are not licensed financial or legal professionals and as such nothing in this article should be understood to be financial or legal advice. If you are in need of financial or legal assistance please seek the help of a competent professional.

Ben Luxon

"Ben is a co-founder, author and real estate enthusiast. His interest in all things entrepreneurial has led him to work with real estate professionals all over the world, distilling their knowledge into articles and Ebooks. His love of travelling has taken him to over 10 countries in the last year, where he has sampled the craft beer of them all."



Also in Articles

costs of owning a rental
The hidden costs of owning a rental home

by Ben Luxon December 04, 2019 4 min read 0 Comments

Owning a rental is a great way to build equity and generate ongoing passive income, but it can also come with a lot more hassle, trouble and expense than people first realize.
Read More
landlords snow removal
Is your rental in the snow? Snow removal equipment you need as a Landlord

by Ben Luxon November 29, 2019 3 min read 0 Comments

As the property owner, you’re responsible for non-compliance with snow removal ordinances, so it’s best if you make sure snow removal equipment is available. You may even find if you check the local bylaws that you are required to keep public thoroughfares that cross our property free from snow too... 

Read More
The Pros & Cons of being a DIY Landlord
The Pros & Cons of being a DIY Landlord

by Ben Luxon November 20, 2019 6 min read 0 Comments

There is a lot to know when you become a landlord and inevitably you’ll make some mistakes early on. These may even be costly mistakes. However, in the long run, once you’ve learned what you need you will become a better more caring landlord than a property management company ever will.
Read More

Join Our Newsletter